By: Samantha Haines
Reg. Animal Health Technologist
Before I even start, I would like to make one thing very clear: The
following is my own personal opinion and does not necessarily reflect the
opinion of the Sechelt Animal Hospital.
There was an editorial in The Province today entitled “It’s time to ban Pit
Bulls in B.C.”.
The opinion of the
author was that B.C. should follow Ontario’s lead in breed banning.
The author mentions an attack on a little
girl named Emma-Leigh, and my heart goes out to her family.
I don’t pretend to know exactly what went down that day with Emma, but in
the article it says that the dog was owned by a neighbor, and that everyone was
together at a BBQ. I know that even the best of dogs can become agitated when
confronted with children, delicious food and lots of people, especially if it’s
all at once; given the circumstances, I am certainly not placing blame on
anyone. Now don't get me wrong, in light of what happened I agree that this
particular dog should be put down, but is banning the breed really going to
solve anything?
I know of a few people that have moved to BC specifically because of the Pit
Bull ban in Ontario. If we start banning the breed here, we are going to lose
more people to other provinces, particularly young people, which (according to
the article) are the primary owner of the breed, and we all know that BC is
drastically lacking young families (especially around the Sunshine Coast).
I am a veterinary professional, I have never been bitten by a pitty, and in fact
I prefer working with Pit Bulls over Chihuahuas or Dachshunds (aka: the Land
Sharks)! At the end of the day, I treat every dog that I see, in or out of my
job, with caution, because they are ALL potentially dangerous; however, they
also ALL have an equal potential to be wonderful.
Pit Bulls are generally gentle creatures and have a high tolerance for pain,
but when and if they bite they can do a lot of damage. True, their jaws are
stronger than most breeds, and they are bred to fight, but they are bred to
fight other dogs, not their owners. There are many other breeds that have been
bred for fighting and/or taking down their prey - Karelian Bear Dog, Akita, Rottweiler
and even the Rhodesian Ridgeback. Should we start banning these breeds by
association?
Then there’s the child-dog dynamic. This can be a wonderful relationship,
but the fact is that 73% of dog bite injuries involve children (regardless of
breed). A child and a dog should never be left alone together. I don't care if
your Aunt says its ok, or your dog has never had a problem with kids. Kids move
fast, they are not always aware of the things in their surroundings, they are
even less aware of canine body language and behavior, and children can be
unpredictable (just like dogs).
Should
we never allow our children to experience the joy that having a dog can bring?
Of course not, but just as we teach our dogs to play nice with children, we
must also teach our children to play nice with dogs.
This involves teaching them about body
language, warning signs, and appropriate responses.
In the online poll this article presents, the public is asked to vote “Yes”
or “No” on whether or not B.C. should ban Pit Bulls. 60% of readers are saying
"NO" to breed bans. This, in my opinion, is not a wide enough margin
to draw conclusive results.
The author
talks about how “Pit Bull owners say many things in defense of their dogs”, but
fails to mention the people who speak against the breed based on hearsay and
myth.
There are only bad owners not bad dogs right? I have heard this many times,
and I agree to some extent, but, as with most things in life, there are two
sides to every story.
Owners do need to
take more responsibility for their dogs, and learn to seriously evaluate if a
breed is right for their lifestyle and personality; for example, a young person
who has had no experience with dogs should not be getting a Pit Bull just
because they like the look of the dog, or just because they like the
breed.
However, a young person with both
dog and breed experience, who has a good understanding of dog behavior and
appropriate training methods would be a great Pit Bull owner.
Unfortunately, people are not always smart
about the decisions they make, and all too often this ends in disaster for the
animals involved.
By the same token, I
believe that any dog has the ability to seriously harm a person under the right
circumstances. Even the most well trained dog is just that... a dog. Their
basic instincts remain unchanged, and we cannot expect them to be little humans
in fur coats.
Why must we all feel the need to take our pets to public events where they
may be put in a circumstance that they are uncomfortable with? I am the first
one to admit that my dogs are part of my family; they were even included in my
wedding ceremony. Yet, I know my dog’s limitations: I know that they are not
comfortable with parades, fireworks, and other large gatherings. It’s not that
I feel that they would hurt someone, but I can tell that they are out of their
comfort zone, and are not enjoying themselves. Now many dogs do, but it is up
to the owner to be able to read your dog’s body language and speak for your
dog. Your dog trusts you and your leadership, therefore you should never put
your dog in a situation where he/she would feel uncomfortable or threatened.
The article says "watch a dog park clear" when a Pit Bull arrives
on the scene. This says absolutely nothing about the dog; however it paints a
very clear picture on society’s perception of the breed. It just means that we
have been made to believe that these dogs are dangerous. I have a German Shepard,
so I often get a similar reaction from the poorly informed public.
People and their dogs cross the street so they
don't have to be near her, but I often find that both frustrating and
enjoyable. On the plus side, I don't have people begging me to pet her, but on
the negative I feel unfairly judged.
IF the breed is to be at fault, perhaps we can make the breeding and ownership
of these dogs more difficult. The people who buy these dogs need to understand
that their dog can be both a dangerous weapon AND a beloved family pet, and as
such should be treated that way.
Instead
of banning the breed, make spaying and neutering mandatory, as well as training
in obedience and body language for both owner and dog.
Breeders should be regularly evaluated according
to strict standards, and dangerously aggressive animals should be culled from
breeding programs.
Maybe this should be
the norm for all dogs regardless of breed.
Links:
Editorial in The Province
Karen Pryor Children and Dogs
Video for kids Part 1, Part 2
Dog bite support group